Studies in Proverbs 10, Part 4: A Biography of Good and Evil

Open water lead above Canada, Arctic Ocean

Part 1, Part 2, Part 3

Text: 10 Whoever winks the eye causes trouble,
but a babbling fool will come to ruin.
11 The mouth of the righteous is a fountain of life,
but the mouth of the wicked conceals violence.
12 Hatred stirs up strife,
but love covers all offenses.
13 On the lips of him who has understanding, wisdom is found,
but a rod is for the back of him who lacks sense.
14 The wise lay up knowledge,
but the mouth of a fool brings ruin near.

Our brief text provides a biography of evil and good. The righteous grow up in wisdom, while the fool grows to master evil schemes. The fool becomes artists of evil. They design everything without thought to the consequences of their actions. Their words start fires around them. Even their very bodily gestures and movements communicate evil. We see this in verses 10: “Whoever winks the eye causes trouble, but a babbling fool will come to ruin.” He is a troublemaker, and everyone around him knows it. Fathers and mothers keep their kids away from him.

What does he do? He winks his eye. He is not being cute or playful. Literally, he is “compressing the eye.” That is, he is meditating on what evil to do next. He is a restless schemer.[1] He stays up late at night strategizing. He doesn’t greet his wife or children; he rushes to his room to plot the next thing. He gives his approval to every societal and cultural evil. But there is a corresponding backlash.[2] It boomerangs back to him. Every evil word or idea comes back to haunt him.

In verse 11, we are back to the antithetical lines: “The mouth of the righteous is a fountain of life, but the mouth of the wicked conceals violence.”

Solomon says four things are a fountain of life: “…the teaching of the wise (13:14); honoring Yahweh (14:27); wisdom (16:22); and the mouth of a righteous person.”  St John says: “Out of his heart will flow rivers of living water.” “The heart is the core of what you are and who you are. Our words will reveal what is really there in our hearts in the long-run.”[3] If you want to live life manufacturing an impression of who you are, eventually, you will be found out. St. James says: “The tongue is set among our members, staining the whole body, setting on fire the entire course of life, and set on fire by hell.” Is it that bad? Are the consequences of our words that earth-shattering? They absolutely are. Our speech needs to be brought under the Lordship of Christ. Our speech needs to be like fresh clean water bringing life wherever it travels. That’s why societies must return to good etiquette and norms, especially between guys and girls.

Verse 13 says: “On the lips of him who has understanding, wisdom is found, but a rod is for the back of him who lacks sense.” Here’s a literal translation to clarify the pairing: “On the lips of the discerning is found wisdom, on the back of a fool, the rod.” The two results: wisdom and a rod.

In our denomination, I think of men like Pastor Mickey Schnider, Randy Booth, Douglas Wilson; men who love and speak wisdom. Wisdom flows from their tongues like a flowing stream of pure water. But have you ever looked at someone’s back and expected it to talk to you? Of course not. That is absurd. Solomon says that when the fool speaks, it is as if his back were speaking. Nothing comes out of it that is beneficial, discerning, or good. What happens to this person? He accumulates so much foolishness that foolishness begets a beating. Foolishness becomes an addictive sport. As Matthew Henry puts it, “(The fools) are preparing rods for themselves, the marks of which will be their perpetual disgrace.”[4] 

On the other hand, verse 14: “The wise lay up knowledge, but the mouth of a fool brings ruin near.” We saw this in verse 10, which says that the babbling fool will come to ruin. He can only talk his way into things for so long, but then it all comes back to bite with a vengeance.

I think if there is something the book of Proverbs makes abundantly clear is the idea of building up and accumulating. We see this pattern in Genesis when God says to the first human beings created: “Have dominion over all things.”[5] This is a pattern throughout the Scriptures. We see this in verse 14. It says: “…the wise lay up knowledge.” Literally, “the wise store up or build up knowledge.” This is what it means to have dominion: it means to build up and store up. Dominion is a long-term project. But what’s the purpose of this storing and building? Everything we gain and everything we have is for others. The wealthy Christian does not grow in possession simply for his own satisfaction and pleasure; no, God gives to him so he may bless and bring peace to others. In the same manner, we see this pattern with wisdom. We are called to have dominion over wisdom. The unbeliever uses his intellect and knowledge for selfish gain, but the believer stores up knowledge so that he not only has sufficient provisions for himself but a supply for others as well.”[6] He is always seeking wisdom. He is asking questions of grown-ups. Succession is the heart of his pursuit. We store wisdom by listening and learning, reading and writing, communing and caring, forgiving one another, and forsaking the company of the fool.

We accumulate wisdom so that others may benefit. The pursuit of wisdom is a succession plan. It is built up to be given to.


[1] Richard Clifford, Proverbs’ commentary.

[2] Bruce Waltke, Commentary on Proverbs.

[3] Professor David McKay.

[4] Commentary on Proverbs found in Bible Works 10.

[5] Genesis 1.

[6] Steve Wilkins.

Studies in Proverbs 10, Part 2

Part 1

A wise son makes a glad father,
but a foolish son is a sorrow to his mother.
Treasures gained by wickedness do not profit,
but righteousness delivers from death.
The Lord does not let the righteous go hungry,
but he thwarts the craving of the wicked.
A slack hand causes poverty,
but the hand of the diligent makes rich.
He who gathers in summer is a prudent son,
but he who sleeps in harvest is a son who brings shame.

Proverbs is deeply interested in the fullness of life. God provides us wise words so we may live a life of wisdom. The salvation of God in history is not simply a broad category to discuss; it is a category to live. God wants to impart wisdom to His people. The danger, of course, is that we become a people so enamored with a desire to know what to do that we become no better than self-help gurus. We don’t want to accumulate a biblical TO-DO list to be wiser than everyone else; instead, we want to learn how to apply the Bible because when we do so, we are more and more conformed unto Christ. This is essential for us to grasp. Proverbs is about Christ. He is the wise Son who always makes His Father glad. So, wisdom is good, but wisdom divorced from Christ is tainted by sin. This is why it is so crucial that when we impart wisdom to our children, we must never end our instruction without pointing them to the Wisdom made flesh, Jesus the Christ. Wisdom leads to works only because we are Christ’s and Christ made us for good works.

Proverbs argues that our works must be done in the sight of God. The works we do is earthy work shattering the nice, civil discourse so prevalent in the so-called elite; in fact, wisdom shatters the elite and makes us all human again. It brings us to the day-to-day struggles from the ivory towers to diaper changing to the sweat of our brows. The type of discourse that typically offends our more refined sensibilities is the type of language the Bible loves to address. Once you grow up into the language of the Bible then, you learn to judge everything else by it.[1]

It is here in these two verses of Proverbs 10 (verses four and five) that we find a sample of the grandiose picture. In Proverbs, wisdom is not ethereal or abstract; it is real and tangible. You can even take a picture of a wise person; that’s how visible it is. Proverbs despises the dichotomy between spiritual and physical. Instead, it loves to unite ideas to the work of your hands.

This is what we find in verses 4 & 5 of Proverbs 10: the unity of wisdom and wealth. Wealth without wisdom is destruction, but wealth with biblical wisdom is to be desired. G.K. Chesterton once said that the central matter of education is not learning things, but unlearning things.[2] Godly pursues righteousness by undoing poor habits.

 Look at verse 4: A slack hand causes poverty, but the hand of the diligent makes rich.” A man’s character is reflected in his attitude toward work.[3] “A diligent man is more than one who works hard; he is one who works efficiently. He recognizes time as a stewardship that must be given account in the Day of Judgment.”[4] What good is it to have wealth and not be wise? As Proverbs 21:20 says, “…the foolish man may take money, but he spends it all up. The hand of the diligent makes rich.”

Man is created to be diligent.[5] And this is why a slack hand produces poverty; not just simply a financial poverty, but a poverty of the mind. A slack hand causes you to think of the world not as a harvest, but as a barren land. Where there is a slack hand, wisdom is not present. Wisdom leads to work and the hand of the diligent makes rich. The practical foundation of wealth, the simple biblical economic principle is that those who are diligent, that is, wise and efficient, become rich. “If you don’t maintain a home it will rot to the ground. Time, nature, and circumstance all conspire to consume and destroy our efforts because we live in a sinful world. Unless people realize that they are responsible for their own financial condition they will never be delivered from poverty.”[6]

This section of Proverbs concludes with a further observation on the contrast between diligence and laziness. Verse 5 says: “He who gathers in summer is a prudent son, but he who sleeps in harvest is a son who brings shame.” There is a a strong contrast in this text. He who gathers in the summer is like the exemplary ant in Proverbs 6:8. Bruce Waltke writes: “He represents any child who brings his parent joy by earning the accolade of being declared prudent.” By contrast, he who sleeps “denotes a person in a state of sleep that is so deep, traumatic, and narcotic-like that he is totally unconscious of his surroundings.” “The fact that he is sleeping in harvest underscores the urgency of the situation.”[7] To be very clear, Solomon is not saying that sleeping or taking a nap is wrong, but what he is saying is that the sleeper “has failed to understand the relationship between timing and success. He has assumed that he can rest at his discretion. The Bible says no…This proverb testifies to the existence of rhythms in life. A man must pace himself according to the conditions of the market. No successful distance runner runs equally fast throughout a long race, irrespective of the conditions of the course, the distance remaining, his energy reserves, and the speed of his competitors.”[8] 

So, we are called to embrace a new rhythm. This rhythm requires us to have a strong commitment to the future. The pessimist works without the expectation of reward and blessing. The hopeful works with the expectation that his labor is not in vain; that God is rewarding and blessing his efforts and building the kingdom upon the work of our hands.


[1] See Against Christianity by Peter Leithart for a fleshing out of these ideas.

[2] Found this quote in Douglas Wilson’s Glory and a Covering.

[3] Ibid.

[4] Rev. Max Doner; sermon on Proverbs 10

[5] Let me also state that Proverbs is assuming that this individual is able to work, but he prefers to keep his hands unharmed from the dangers of the ground, or a keyboard, or whatever it is one may do for work.

[6] Ibid. see sermonaudio.com

[7] Ibid.

[8] Gary North, Economic Commentary on the Book of Proverbs.

What can we learn from the Josh Duggar scandal?

By now the entire Christian community is aware of the Duggar debacle. Josh Duggar, son to Jim Bob and Michelle Duggar, has not only been found out for his despicable acts of molesting five girls in 2002, but also his name turned up when hackers released stolen customer data from cheating site AshleyMadison.com earlier in the week. So far social media celebrity, Matt Walsh, has apologized for giving Josh a pass after the molestation revelations. Walsh used his gigantic platform to treat Josh as a victim of leftist propaganda. If I could summarize Walsh’s first reaction, it would be like this: “Yes, he sinned, but don’t you see why the left is making such a big deal out of this? This is a selective political sniper kill.” The good news is that Walsh’s most recent statement has been very clear in his criticism. Here is a lengthy quote:

So I was wrong about Josh Duggar being a repentant man. Clearly, he isn’t. Or at least he wasn’t. Maybe now he’ll finally begin the process, but it’s certainly impossible to believe that someone could be truly sorry for past sexual sin while currently in the process of fishing for affairs and “experimental” one night stands.

He’s a traitor to his family. I feel awful for them, and I pray that Josh really does come to Christ. Beyond that, I pray his wife and kids somehow recover from all of the shame Josh has brought upon them. Because, let’s be clear, if you sign up for an adultery website and then your information gets hacked and your family ends up embarrassed and devastated — that is YOUR fault. You are the one who victimized them. The hackers acted illegally, but this all happened because of your choices. Don’t want your information stolen from an adultery website? Don’t sign up for an adultery website. Pretty simple formula.

I must also admit that the more I think about this, I realized I was too easy on the the Duggar parents as well. Jim Bob and Michelle knew that their oldest son was struggling with severe sexual sin, they knew their daughters had been abused, they knew their family was in the midst of moral and spiritual turmoil, yet they STILL decided to put themselves and their children on TV for ten years.

I hope others will take the same path and recognize that no matter what royal family one is born into and no matter the influential position he may have in the culture war, no man should be exempt from the lawful discipline of the Church or state, or both.

I concur. Josh Duggar is guilty. Repentance bears fruit (Lk. 3:8). There is a long continuous pattern of sexual misconduct  by Josh Duggar. At this point we should stop and think why are we so comfortable giving a pass to these Christian celebrities? And then we should consider very carefully how we can begin fighting passionately to protect the many victims in our culture who suffer at the hands of such men, but yet are trivialized into a category of “wrong place and wrong time.” Where is the safest environment for them to be restored and emotionally healed from such torments? Who will care for their trauma? The difference is vast.

I am deeply saddened for Josh’s wife and children who will have to live and re-live these awful events due to hyped media attention. As for Josh, words of contrition only go so far. His next few years will prove whether his repentance is genuine or not. I have learned long ago that not all sin is created equal. Repentance can be easily couched in evangelical lingo. Those who defended Josh Duggar without second thought or who assumed his initial incoherent words of confession made everything just fine or who treated repentance like some nebulous concept divorced from the reality of the pain caused to victims will hopefuly have learned a significant lesson: God is not mocked. Sins are not inconsequential. This is not a left vs. right issue. This is an issue of morality  and God has made clear that his justice will not be in vain. Josh Duggar affirmed that, “He is the biggest hyprocrite ever.” But hypocrisy can only be dealt with by understanding what God hates and what he loves.

Paul spoke of temptations that are stunningly difficult to face. When he says “flee from temptation” he is not simply using a 1st century  bumper sticker. This is more profound. Paul’s context is an ecclesiastical one where confession and collective sorrow manifests themselves continually in a community of grace. But even then sin is subtle. You must flee temptation, but you must first understand what temptation looks like. Yahweh speaks about the seven sins that he hates and provides this list as a step-by-step calculation made by those who embrace evil:

16 There are six things which Jehovah hateth; Yea, seven which are an abomination unto him:

17 Haughty eyes, a lying tongue, And hands that shed innocent blood;

18 A heart that deviseth wicked purposes, Feet that are swift in running to mischief,

19 A false witness that uttereth lies, And he that soweth discord among brethren.

Duggar’s long history of sexual perversions was not born after a particularly miserable day. There is a pattern of thought and action. There is an anatomy of evil involved. There is a whole-body determination to follow these sins from the eyes to the feet. There is a calculated narrative that culminated in sexual abuse and adultery. For those who do evil the feast of the wicked is incredibly appetizing. One drink leads to another and only increases the hunger.

Where do we begin then? If situations like this do not cause us (particularly men) to be ever cautious then we will not have learned from it. Every person’s crime is a reason to re-consider our strategies to fighting sin and living righteously. If I had five minutes to counsel Josh I would tell him to look at this list and begin to detail where his narrative went awry. Where and when did his eyes become arrogant and haughty? At what point did he think he was invincible? At what point did he rationalize the presence of God away from his actions in secret? Then, when did he begin to put into words his pride by lying about his reality? I would be sure to point him to Jesus; not the Jesus that dismisses sins, but rather takes them with utmost seriousness and urges him to put on Christ and put off the deeds of darkness.

Josh needs to re-consider this list. He needs to see grace as redeeming the mind and abolishing calculated plans for evil. God has plans of his own. His plans involve demolishing our plans and replacing them with plans that are good, true, and beautiful. The task is great. Josh is only a clear example due to his high profile status. There are many Joshes out there currently afraid that they may be found out; afraid that their secret adventures will come out in Duggar fashion. The good news is God has already found you out. The bad news is that God has already found you out. In the end of the day to be found out by God is the best news. His throne is justice. He makes no mistake. His discipline will hurt, but it will not damn you. Accept it. Receive it. Confess it. Find refuge in Him.

Dear Sister: Response on Forgiveness

Dear sister,a

You have stated that the common view of forgiveness indicates that you are supposed to forgive the man who harmed you physically, psychologically, and perpetually as you go about your day. Though you are no longer under his control–thanks be to God–you still suffer the immense pain and agony by re-living those moments every time–or almost every time–someone uses certain language, when someone jokes about abuse, when someone sounds like an abuser, and when someone trivializes that abuse. So, you are told, suck it up! Live with it! Move on and forgive him.

My responses to these requests are meant to be brief, but to the point. Forgiveness is not a dispensing machine. An abuser cannot simply press a button and demand that you act accordingly. So, principle number one is that if the abuser demands forgiveness from you and acts as if he deserves it, tell him that you are a human being and that you will not be treated like a machine. Forgiveness, if you wish to be theological, is covenantal.

Forgiveness is complex at this level. Not all relationships are created equal. At the very least, this conversation between victim and abuser can only be initiated if said abuser has changed his ways, proven that he has suffered the consequences of his actions, has placed himself in a community where his sins are known, and if the case involves sexual abuse, that he not be working near any children. If those conditions are met, then by all means begin the conversation if you are prepared. But though he may be ready to proceed and though the conditions are met, make sure that you are surrounded by a safe community, with a pastor (s) that understand the severity of the damage done and have agreed to walk with you through this process.

Dismiss any comment from counselors who make you feel guilty for suffering such abuse. Better yet, run away from them.  You may think you have found an advocate, but you really are dealing with someone with little capacity to understand the depths of human pain. I pray you will find a voice of reason in a sea of miserable counsel.

Yours truly,

Uri Brito

  1. These names will remain anonymous  (back)

“He That Winneth Souls is Wise”, An Exegetical Comment on Proverbs 11:30b

Evangelistic rallies, tent revivals, and door-knocking gospel programs appeal to Proverbs 11:30 as justification for their conversion agendas. The old King James translates it as “He that winneth souls is wise.” The great Baptist preacher, Charles Spurgeon, used this as proof-text for evangelistic endeavors. While a call to arms to invade neighborhoods with tracts and pamphlets may be a worthwhile endeavor, this passage has been poorly misused by well-intentioned Christians, and should therefore be cautiously used.

Solomon has been building a strong case ever since the beginning of verse one of chapter 11. The matter here is life versus death in the realm of wisdom. Wisdom leads to a fructiferous life whereas foolishness leads to destruction. Verse 11 in the ESV says “…and whoever captures souls is wise.” The Hebrew loqeah mepasot usually implies the “taking of lives” as in “to kill.” Yet this does not make sense out of the context, since the “wise” is the subject of the verb. A direct translational read would be unhelpful at this point, and would seem to minimize Solomon’s argument.

The better approach to this section of verse 30 is to parallel Solomon’s words to the central theme of Proverbs (1:3), which is to “receive instruction” or to “comprehend instruction.” There is then a parallel between 11:30a and 11:30b. The tree of life is a reference to the wise who “gathers/plucks/captures life from death. The wise is like a strong green leaf filled with energy and abundance. As Paul Koptak summarizes: “This is an envcouragement to become wise in order to save not only one’s own life/soul but also the lives of others.”

The wise man, the man who bears good fruit (Ps. 1:3) is a man who is deeply interested in the rescuing of those who abide in wickedness and whose choices are leading them on the crooked paths (Prov. 11:20). One must be wise, in order to provide life for the unwise.

In summary, there are evangelistic implications to this passage, but any form of evangelism needs to be grounded in wisdom, rather than a quick 4-step plan to conversion. If there is an evangelistic implication to this passage it is that placing new Christians at the forefront of these endeavors may be unwise since he lacks maturity and biblical knowledge to communicate the wisdom of Yahweh to the world. Solomonic wisdom offers unbelievers more than simply a quick way to heaven, but the very offer of heaven on earth to those who have despised kingly wisdom.

P.S. As Tim Russel observed in a conversation we had, there is a danger of interpreting this as “only the theologically astute can evangelize.” This is not what I wish to convey, so it is an important reminder. In order to best reflect this skepticism, I changed that sentence to this: “…it may be unwise since he lacks maturity and biblical knowledge to communicate the wisdom of Yahweh to the world.”

As Daniel Hoffman observed on FB, there is some type of interaction between Solomon in Proverbs 11:30 and Genesis 3. I have suggested:

One way to consider this is to assert that finding life or being joined into a wisdom/tree implies dying first. Therefore, rescuing necessitates death…abandoning foolishness and embracing wisdom is a form of death.

{Thanks for the interactions of Tim Russell and Daniel Hoffman}

 

Sermon: A Call to Faithful Presence, Proverbs 11:12-19, Kingly Wisdom, Part IX

People of God,  Proverbs is a book of wisdom. It is applicable to our day, it is worthy of our investment, it is healthy to be memorized, it is powerful in counseling, effective in discerning, faithful in its consistency, paradoxical in its diversity, accurate in presenting the antithesis, strong in its denunciation, and bold in its wisdom. And when you consider the nature of Proverbs, it is simply a manual for parents to train their children. In particular, Solomon is discipling his son to be a king, and by implication we know that ultimately this is Jesus training his children to be Kings and Queens in this world.

Echoing my sermon last week, the city is ours because it belongs to our King, Jesus Christ. So we can’t simply go to the Court House and tell the judge that he needs to step down because we have a Christian replacement for him. We cannot simply go on theorizing hoping that leaders of the community will come to our front door and offer us an important seat. There is work to be done. We need to have a faithful presence. Faithfulness is our daily duties. It is by example that our Lord taught us to live. In other words, we need to first change diapers before we can opine about the woes of the world. We need to first take the trash out before cleaning the world. We need to first do the hard work of establishing a good and faithful testimony before the world can look to us and desire what we have and put us in places of leadership. Continue reading “Sermon: A Call to Faithful Presence, Proverbs 11:12-19, Kingly Wisdom, Part IX”